Available Friday-Sunday at 10am on a rotating schedule (see below).
Due to high demand and limited refrigeration space, we do not accept advanced pre-orders for Cream Pies outside of Weddings and Large Event Orders.
For more information on Weddings and Events, please visit our Special Orders page.
How To Purchase a Cream Pie
Pick up a pie in person Friday-Sunday starting at 10am. Our Cream Pies are pretty popular and we do often sell out so we recommend coming right at opening if you have a particular pie in mind.
Place a same-day phone order Friday-Sunday starting at Noon (12pm). You can call the shop to place your order over the phone with payment. If the pie is still available, they will hold the order for you until your pickup time the same day.
Note: June 18th-20th all Cream Pies will be First Come, First Serve for Father's Day Weekend. We will not be accepting same-day phone orders 6/18-6/20.
Cream Pie Schedule
June 11th-13th: Huckleberry Cream & Coconut Cream
June 18th-20th: Cookies 'n Cream & Lemon Cream w/Raspberry (whole pies only, no slices)
June 25th-27th: Peanut Butter Bliss & Banana Cream
July 2nd-4th: Raspberry Cream & White Chocolate w/Strawberries & Blueberries (whole pies only, no slices)
July 9th-11th: Huckleberry Cream & Key Lime
July 16th-18th: Lemon Cream w/Raspberry & Chocolate Cream